Exploring How Income, Race and Design Affect Pedestrian Casualties
Lower income communities experience fully three times the number of pedestrian deaths and injuries per capita as do affluent ones.
Pedestrian fatalities in the United States have increased more than 50% over the last decade, with 1 in 6 traffic deaths involving pedestrians. Programs like Vision Zero and Safe Systems focus on making transportation safe for vulnerable users, primarily pedestrians, based on the assumption that pedestrian-related improvements will enhance safety regardless of where they are applied.
Despite the widespread implementation of these programs, they have generally failed to reduce traffic-related deaths and injuries. Even cities that have most aggressively adopted Vision Zero, like New York, Washington D.C., Seattle and Portland, have seen increases in traffic-related fatalities and injuries after implementing these programs.
Research from Florida Atlantic University examined the environmental factors associated with crash incidence in lower-income and more affluent areas in Broward and Palm Beach counties, finding that much of the failure of these programs may be attributed to the failure to direct pedestrian safety improvements to the areas and populations that would most benefit from them.
Results of the study, published earlier this year in the journal Transportation Research Record, show that the nature of pedestrian crash risk is markedly different in lower income communities than in more affluent ones. Lower income communities experience fully three times the number of pedestrian deaths and injuries per capita as do affluent ones.
The environmental factors associated with crash risk in these areas differ as well. For lower-income communities, pedestrian deaths and injuries increase with traffic volumes, multilane streets, and presence of restaurants and shopping centers. These variables all suggest that, at least in lower-income areas, pedestrian death and injury is associated with difficulties safely accessing household-supporting destinations.
For affluent areas, the factors associated with increased pedestrian death and injury were those relating to recreation and nightlife – specifically, bars and clubs, hotels and restaurants – rather than essential household travel. Neither high traffic volumes nor multilane “arterial” roads, which tend to be the focus of Vision Zero-related safety programs, were meaningfully related to pedestrian death or injury in affluent areas.
Although pedestrian crashes often are attributed to pedestrians walking under the influence of drugs or alcohol, it appears that walking under the influence is principally an issue for affluent populations, rather than lower income ones. Bars and nightclubs were only associated with increased pedestrian crashes in affluent areas, with pedestrians struck by a vehicle in affluent ones being twice as likely to have been suspected of being under the influence of drugs and alcohol than those in lower income ones.
“Pedestrians in lower-income areas are likely to be struck by a car because they are trying to access everyday needs like food and shopping in environments that are poorly designed,” said Eric Dumbaugh, Ph.D., senior author and a professor in the Department of Urban and Regional Planning, within FAU’s Charles E. Schmidt College of Science. “This isn’t the problem in affluent areas. If a street feels unsafe, they don’t need to walk. They simply drive instead.”
The researchers note that streetscape projects intended to advance economic development objectives or to enhance the lifestyle preferences of affluent communities are often heralded as “safety improvements,” despite little evidence to suggest that such improvements will result in reductions to crash risk.
“There is a tendency to prioritize pedestrian projects in affluent areas where pedestrian safety isn’t really a problem. If we want to get serious about pedestrian safety, we need to begin directing safety improvements to the areas that will most benefit from them,” said Dumbaugh. “Looking forward, the definition of vulnerability incorporated in road safety programs needs to be understood not simply as a function of a human body’s physical tolerance for trauma, but also as an outcome of underlying social disparities, with race and income particularly relevant risk factors.”
Study co-authors are Jonathan Stiles, Ph.D., a post-doctoral researcher at FAU; Diana Mitsova, Ph.D., chair and professor of FAU’s Department of Urban and Regional Planning; and Dibakar Saha, Ph.D., Florida Department of Transportation.
This project was partially supported by grants from the Florida Department of Transportation and the Collaborative Sciences Center for Road Safety, based at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, a U.S. Department of Transportation National University Transportation Center promoting safety.
-FAU-
Latest News Desk
- Tech Runway Entrepreneur Wins Funding from 'Sharks' at FAU's CrocTankAn entrepreneur from Florida Atlantic University's Tech Runway was offered $250,000 during CrocTank, a first-of-its-kind live business pitch event recently hosted with the judges from ABC's show "Shark Tank."
- FAU Awarded $6M Grant to Expand Marcus Institute of Integrative HealthThe grant from the late Bernie Marcus and The Marcus Foundation will enable the FAU Marcus Institute of Integrative Health to expand its operations to provide more services and conduct more research.
- FAU Adds State-of-the-Art MRI System to Advance Research CapabilitiesFAU has added a new state-of-the-art MRI system to its research infrastructure, marking a transformative step forward for groundbreaking studies in neuroscience, clinical health and medical advancements.
- FAU Hosts ABC's 'Sharks' for First-of-its-Kind CompetitionThe judges of ABC's "Shark Tank" will be coming to Florida Atlantic University for its very own CrocTank, the first-of-its-kind live event on Dec. 4 at the Carole and Barry Kaye Performing Arts Auditorium.
- Arslan Munir, Ph.D., Pioneer in Smart Technologies, Joins FAUThe FAU College of Engineering and Computer Science recently welcomed Arslan Munir, Ph.D., an internationally renowned expert, researcher and pioneer in advanced computing and smart technologies.
- VR Could be a Gamechanger in Police-Civilian Crisis EncountersAn FAU College of Social Work and Criminal Justice study immersed police officers in virtual reality training using a realistic mental illness scenario to enhance empathy and complement traditional training.