‘It went nowhere’: FAU Faculty Senate echoes concerns about presidential search criteria
As the fall 2024 semester comes to a close, the Florida Atlantic University Faculty Senate held its final meeting on Monday, Dec. 2.
The senators discussed the presidential search, academic freedom and student enrollment.
The Presidential Search
Faculty Senate President Kimberly Dunn started off the meeting with an update about the presidential search. At the last Board of Trustees (BOT) meeting on Nov. 20, the board approved a “position criteria” document that highlights the university’s achievements and sets qualifications for the Presidential Search Committee to look for in a presidential candidate.
“I and some of my fellow trustees expressed some concern about how the minimum qualifications were stated,” said Dunn. She was referring specifically to page 32 of the document entitled “Preferred Expertise, Skills and Attributes,” where it states that the board requires a “Terminal degree or significant professional achievement, recognition and prestige.”
To Dunn and others, the word “or” is problematic here, because this implies that they don’t have to hire someone with a strong background in higher education. She said so long as they deem someone with arbitrary achievement significant then that is enough to be president.
Dunn, as a member of the BOT, spoke up about that concern on behalf of the faculty at the recent meeting.
“It went nowhere with the Board of Trustees,” she said.
She then announced that the Presidential Search Committee expects to have named candidates by January. The faculty seemed unnerved by this announcement.
Bill Trapani, who is part of the Faculty Senate’s Steering Committee and is a faculty advisor for the Presidential Search Committee, thanked Dunn for her efforts. He asked who would feel more comfortable if the future president had a background in higher education.
An overwhelming majority of members raised their hands to this request.
“I will, when I get the opportunity, do my work to relay that to the committee,” said Trapani.
Academic freedom
Dunn and Dawn Rothe, the chair of the Academic Freedom and Due Process Committee, presented a resolution to reaffirm the Faculty Senate’s commitment to academic freedom. This resolution follows a set of concerns that Senate members relayed to the academic freedom committee.
“We stand in solidarity with the AAUP’s Core Principles on academic freedom, to wit. Academic freedom is the freedom of a teacher or researcher in higher education to investigate and discuss the issues in his or her academic field, and to teach and publish findings without interference from administrators, boards of trustees, political figures, donors or other entities,” the statement reads.
It continues to state that academic freedom should protect the rights of faculty members to speak freely as a citizen, as well as when participating in institutional governance.
Another member of the Senate’s Steering Committee, LeaAnne DeRigne expressed frustration during the discussion, as she feels the resolutions passed in meetings do not lead to tangible action.
“What happens with these statements? Like after we vote on them, what do we do with them?” asked DeRigne.
Dunn explained that the statements go to the Faculty Senate’s website. Sometimes resolutions get covered by news publications, or other universities pass similar resolutions as a result.
“But in reality, it’s not a lot,” said Dunn, as the resolution passed with no opposition.
DeRigne responded in an email to the University Press on Dec. 3, explaining why she raised the concern. She mentioned that she wanted to understand the fate of these resolutions and for their impact to be better. She emphasized that they are essential and noted that the resolution passed at the meeting was a strong demonstration of support for academic freedom.
“I have spoken at several Faculty Senate meetings over the last few months to express my concerns about the infringement on academic freedom and to highlight how the actions of the State Board of Governors are undermining the overall strength of higher education in Florida,” she wrote.
Enrollment planning
James Capp, the associate vice president for strategic planning and student success, spoke about FAU’s priorities and future plans for student enrollment.
According to Capp, the university’s first year of offering early decision applications is going well. He said that as of Dec. 1, there were 38,363 applications already submitted for the fall 2025 term.
He addressed concerns about the university’s housing capacity, with more new students being admitted every year. Capp noted that FAU will continue to waitlist students for housing so as not to overburden the university.
Capp also pointed to FAU’s Boca Raton Campus Master Plan, which outlines a new residence hall expected to be completed in 2026.
Caroline Ribeiro is a contributing writer for the University Press. For information regarding this or other stories, email cribeiro2021@fau.edu or message her on Instagram @carolpardiniribeiro.
Latest University Press
- Football: Zach Kittley is FAU football’s next head coachFormer Texas Tech University offensive coordinator (OC) Zach Kittley has been announced as FAU football’s next head coach, per Twitter (X) tonight at 7:06 p.m. Florida Atlantic finished their season 3-9, under the leadership of former head coach Tom Herman. He served for the Owls for two seasons and was fired about two weeks ago...
- Holiday break or breaking point? Addressing food and family pressures in college studentsReconnecting with family after months apart for the holiday season can present challenging obstacles for students in general. While conversations about the academic year can already feel overwhelming, they may also face uncomfortable questions about their appearance or eating habits. For college students like Laelani Perez, an FAU exercise science and health promotion senior, the...
- Men’s Basketball: FAU bested by FGCU in heartbreaking buzzer beaterOn Nov. 30, Florida Atlantic’s men’s basketball team (4-5) had their first game at home since Nov. 8. They had a two week stretch in Charleston, S.C. for the Field of 68 Tipoff and the Charleston Classic. In their second buzzer beater of the season, the Owls fell 80-78 to Florida Gulf Coast University Eagles...
- AI revolution in higher education: College professors navigate new territoryAs artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT and Claude evolve, so do universities’ responses to the digital shift. Institutions are quickly developing new strategies, from reshaping curriculums to appointing AI-focused roles, to prepare students for an AI-driven future. Florida Atlantic University is among several state universities already grappling with how to best find uses for AI...
- Letter to the Editor: FAU lacks appropriate dining hours for studentsFlorida Atlantic University students cannot get a meal on campus past 10 p.m. and this is a problem. For the 4,000 students who live on the Boca Raton campus, there is no dining option available after 10 p.m. Students are faced with three choices: leave campus and open their wallets to drive-thrus, order food on...
- Football: FAU fumbles final home game of the season to University of North Carolina at CharlotteFlorida Atlantic University (2-9, 0-7 AAC) squandered a late lead against the University of North Carolina at Charlotte (4-7, 3-4 AAC). A late fumble by quarterback Tyriq Starks in his first start sealed the game in Charlotte’s favor, 39-27. With QB1 Cam Fancher out, Starks stepped up with 179 passing yards and a touchdown. Stark’s...